16. BSD Unix, Part 6 - The Struggle for Freedom
- BSD Unix, Part 1 - Unix Code Goes to UC Berkeley
- BSD Unix, Part 2 - The Birth of the vi Editor
- BSD Unix, Part 3 - The Beginning of BSD Unix
- BSD Unix, Part 4 - The Formation of CSRG
- BSD Unix, Part 5 - Bringing TCP/IP to BSD
BSD Unix, Part 6
The Struggle for Freedom

Early Unix was available through inexpensive source-code licenses because a 1956 antitrust settlement kept AT&T out of the commercial computer business [6]. Some early licenses cost just $99 [1].
Too cheap.
One tape,
please.
Schools
too?
Companies
too?
Research
labs too?
Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) also valued Unix's source-code availability. That was why it chose BSD Unix over DEC's VMS for building the Internet [1].

But AT&T's breakup in 1984 opened the way for it to sell Unix commercially. AT&T abruptly raised the price from $99 to $250,000 [1].
AT&T Unix fees
Khh...
BSD still required an AT&T license. When fees rose, some companies wanted its networking code separately.
How can I get just BSD's
TCP/IP and vi source code?
AT&T's raised the fees.
Users want just our
networking code and tools.
Let's release our
networking code
and tools separately.
How's the release
coming?
Fine. What about
the license?
Let's write our own BSD
license. BSD users can use
our code freely. They just
need to put the copyright
notice in the manual if
they make a product or
redistribute the source.
That'll throw AT&T off.
Anything goes, huh? Well, we don't want to put
restrictions on people like AT&T does.
CSRG released its networking code and utilities as Networking Release 1 (Net/1) in June 1989. Its new BSD license allowed use without an AT&T source license. People could modify the code or redistribute it as source or binaries without paying Berkeley royalties. They had to retain the source copyright notices and credit UC Berkeley and its contributors in product documentation.

BSD's networking release
is finally here.
How
much?
They'll mail you a tape
for $1,000. Or download it
free by FTP. We can even
change and redistribute
the code without royalties.
Meanwhile, at CSRG
Professor, the networking
release is selling well.
Grants, tape sales...
Development's funded
for a while.
Time for the weekly meeting.
Professor, why don't we make a version of BSD
that doesn't require an AT&T Unix license?
We can't keep depending on AT&T.
We've already changed much of the kernel.
It's the tools and C library we need to rewrite.
Can we do it quickly?
Let's try. With help from
outside contributors, we can
rewrite the AT&T code.
CSRG decided to rewrite AT&T's tools and C library. With help from outside contributors, most of the code was rewritten in eighteen months.

With most of AT&T's Unix code removed, a completely free BSD Unix was finally released in June 1991. The source was still available on tape for the $1,000 copying fee, or as a free download by FTP.
Now we can sell
BSD Unix too.
CSRG founded a company called BSDi to sell BSD Unix commercially. The University of California also began selling BSD Unix in the early 1990s. An advertisement claimed it was 95% cheaper than AT&T Unix. That did not go down well with AT&T.

The Empire Strikes Back
In April 1992, AT&T subsidiary USL sued BSDi. UC Berkeley was added to the lawsuit later.
I thought we'd removed
all the AT&T code...
What's this?
But AT&T's Unix System V also included plenty of BSD code, such as virtual memory, TCP/IP and vi. The BSD license allowed anyone to use the code if they kept the copyright notices. AT&T removed those notices from the source and sold Unix as though it had written all the code itself.

AT&T's suing us for distributing
Unix code without permission.
That's absurd. System V includes
our virtual memory, TCP/IP
and vi code.
Exactly. We should
countersue.
The BSD side filed a countersuit against AT&T.

In February 1994, the two sides agreed that each could sell Unix, provided CSRG removed some remaining AT&T Unix code.

It's the same code...
Wouldn't want his job.
Although BSD Unix began with AT&T's code, much of it had been rewritten, and evidence had emerged that AT&T had incorporated BSD's TCP/IP, virtual memory and vi code while removing copyright notices. But legal uncertainty hung over BSD distribution during the lawsuit, and the two years lost before a completely free BSD Unix appeared gave Linux room to grow.
If I could have installed BSD Unix
on my Intel 386 PC,
I wouldn't have needed to write Linux.
That wraps up our six-part story of BSD Unix!
References
- Andrew Leonard, BSD Unix: Power to the people, from the code, 2000
- Marshall Kirk McKusick, Twenty Years of Berkeley Unix: From AT&T-Owned to Freely Redistributable, in Open Sources: Voices from the Open Source Revolution, O'Reilly, 1999
- Computer Systems Research Group
- The Design and Implementation of the 4.4BSD Operating System: Network Implementation
- Mike Linksvayer, Interview with Linus Torvalds, Meta Magazine, 1993
- Federal Judicial Center, The Breakup of "Ma Bell": United States v. AT&T
- Dennis Ritchie, Old Unix Licenses and Price Lists